| Game |
| Players |
Yards |
Opponent |
Year |
| John Reinhardt to Harvey Bunker |
98 yards |
Pinckneyville |
1965 |
| Andrew Kash to Royce Newman |
88 yards |
Athens |
2015 |
| Cole Malawy to Jaxon Goforth |
84 yards |
Carlyle |
2019 |
| Brady Harre to Gannon Mamell |
83 yards |
Anna Jonesboro |
2009 |
| Cole Malawy to Isaac Turner |
82 yards |
Benton |
2020 |
| Kim Morris to Joel Thorson |
80 yards |
Greenville |
1986 |
| Hayden Klingeman to Samuel Kollbaum |
80 yards |
Benton |
2024 |
| Kolten Gajewski to Ben Reid |
78 yards |
Pana |
2021 |
| Hayden Klingeman to Samuel Kollbaum |
77 yards |
Benton |
2024 |
| Andrew Kash to Ethan Reid |
75 yards |
Massac County |
2016 |
| Drew Ibendahl to John Schmale |
75 yards |
Pinckneyville |
2000 |
| Cole Malawy to Isaac Turner |
TBA |
Carterville |
2020 |
| Cole Malawy to Nick Miller |
TBA |
Mater Dei |
2020 |